Construction (C): Building Classifications and Fire-Resistant Design

The "C" in COPE stands for Construction, and it represents one of the most significant factors affecting your commercial property insurance premium. Of all the COPE factors, construction type has the most dramatic impact on insurance costs because it fundamentally determines how fire-resistant your building is.

A modern steel and concrete office building and a wood-frame warehouse might have identical square footage, similar occupancy (office work), and the same fire suppression systems. Yet the modern building will have property insurance roughly 40-60% lower than the wood-frame building—purely because of construction differences.

Understanding building construction classifications is essential for property owners evaluating purchases, facility managers planning renovations, and anyone seeking to understand their property insurance costs.

The Fundamentals of Construction Classification

Insurance construction classification is primarily about fire resistance. The basic principle is straightforward: buildings that better resist fire are cheaper to insure. This reflects both the reduced likelihood of catastrophic loss and the reduced severity if fire does occur.

Why Construction Matters So Much

Construction affects insurance premiums more dramatically than other building characteristics because:

1. Fire resistance directly correlates with loss severity - A wood-frame building that catches fire is more likely to burn completely; a concrete building may contain the fire
2. Replacement cost varies with construction - Total loss replacement costs are typically highest for wood-frame buildings (complete destruction), lower for concrete/steel (partial loss more likely)
3. Fire spread potential - Combustible construction allows fire to spread through walls and floors; non-combustible construction limits spread
4. Recovery time - Rebuilding concrete/steel structures takes longer but results in better outcomes; rebuilding wood often means total loss
5. Historical loss data - Over 100 years of claims data shows clear correlation between construction type and loss experience

The insurance principle is simple: more fire-resistant = lower expected losses = lower premiums.

The Six Construction Classes

Commercial property insurance uses a systematic classification of buildings into six construction classes, ranging from Class 1 (most combustible) to Class 6 (most fire-resistant). These classifications are based on the primary structural materials—the materials that form the building's exterior walls and structural frame.

Construction Types Comparison Gallery

Class 1: Wood Frame Construction

Definition: Buildings with exterior walls and structural frame primarily constructed of wood or other combustible materials.

Characteristics:

• Exterior walls: Wood siding, wood sheathing, or combustible material
• Roof: Wood rafters and wood decking, often with wood shingles or combustible roofing
• Structural frame: Wood posts, beams, and joists
• Interior structure: Wood studs, wood joists, wood trim
• Roofing material: Often wood shingles or other combustible material
• Examples: Older homes, older apartment buildings, some older commercial structures, warehouses built with wood construction

Fire Behavior:

• Maximum combustibility: Wood frame buildings are the most combustible construction type
• Rapid fire spread: Fire spreads quickly through wall cavities and between floors
• Complete loss potential: Fire can destroy entire building structure
• Total loss likely: Most structural fires in wood frame result in total loss
• Severe loss history: Insurance claims from fires in wood-frame buildings tend to be catastrophic

Insurance Premium Impact:

• Highest base rates: Class 1 buildings have the highest insurance rates of any construction class
• Example base rates: $3.50-$5.00 per $100 of property value (varies by occupancy)
• Premium for $1M building: $35,000-$50,000 annually (base rate only, before occupancy and exposure adjustments)
• Relative cost: 2.5-3x higher than Class 6 building

Premium Examples by Location and Occupancy:

• Wood warehouse in moderate area: ~$4.50/100 value
• Old wood apartment building: ~$5.00/100 value
• Wood office building: ~$3.50/100 value

Renovation Impact: Major renovation that converts exterior to non-combustible could potentially improve classification to Class 2 or 3, reducing premiums by 20-40%.

Class 2: Non-Combustible Construction (Wood Roof)

Definition: Buildings with non-combustible exterior walls but combustible roof construction.

Characteristics:

• Exterior walls: Brick, concrete block, tile, stone, or other non-combustible masonry
• Roof: Wood rafters and wood decking (the combustible element)
• Structural frame: May be wood, steel, or concrete
• Interior: Often mixed combustible and non-combustible
• Roofing material: May be wood shingles, tar and gravel, or non-combustible material
• Examples: Older brick commercial buildings with wood roofs, mid-20th century masonry structures, many downtown commercial buildings built 1950s-1970s

Fire Behavior:

• Better than Class 1: Non-combustible walls limit fire spread horizontally
• Roof is weak point: Wood roof construction is the limiting factor
• Partial loss more likely than total loss: Building structure survives but roof burns
• Fire damage contained: Fire is less likely to spread beyond the roof area
• Moderate loss history: Claims are less catastrophic than Class 1

Insurance Premium Impact:

• Moderate base rates: Class 2 has significantly lower rates than Class 1
• Example base rates: $2.00-$3.00 per $100 of property value
• Premium for $1M building: $20,000-$30,000 annually
• Relative cost: 1.5-2x higher than Class 6

Renovation Impact: Replacing wood roof with non-combustible material could potentially allow reclassification to Class 3, reducing premiums by 10-20%.

Class 3: Masonry Non-Combustible Construction

Definition: Buildings with non-combustible masonry walls and non-combustible or partially-protected roof.

Characteristics:

• Exterior walls: Brick, concrete block, stone masonry
• Roof: Non-combustible material (tile, concrete, metal) OR wood with fire-resistant treatment
• Structural frame: Often iron/steel or reinforced concrete
• Interior: Mix of combustible and non-combustible (protected combustibles acceptable)
• Examples: Typical mid-century brick buildings, many urban commercial buildings, some industrial structures with masonry exterior

Fire Behavior:

• Good fire resistance: Masonry walls and non-combustible roof provide excellent fire containment
• Fire spread limited: Fire tends to be contained within the building area of origin
• Structural survivability: Building structure typically survives fire (though interior may be destroyed)
• Moderate to low loss history: Claims are typically not total loss

Insurance Premium Impact:

• Moderate base rates: Class 3 rates are substantially lower than Classes 1-2
• Example base rates: $1.50-$2.25 per $100 of property value
• Premium for $1M building: $15,000-$22,500 annually
• Relative cost: 1.3-1.8x higher than Class 6

Common for Many Buildings: Class 3 is the typical classification for many urban and suburban commercial buildings built 1950s-1980s.

Class 4: Masonry with Steel Frame Non-Combustible

Definition: Buildings with masonry walls and steel frame construction with protected steel elements.

Characteristics:

• Exterior walls: Masonry (brick, concrete block, stone)
• Structural frame: Steel (columns, beams, joists) with fire-resistant treatment
• Roof: Non-combustible material
• Interior: Protected steel with non-combustible protection
• Interior walls/floors: Typically concrete with steel support
• Examples: Modern commercial buildings, many contemporary industrial facilities, newer downtown buildings

Fire Behavior:

• Very good fire resistance: Steel frame protected with non-combustible materials provides excellent containment
• Steel protection critical: Unprotected steel loses strength when heated; protected steel maintains integrity
• Structural integrity maintained: Building structure typically remains sound after fire
• Low loss severity: Fire damage typically localized to area of origin
• Low loss history: Insurance claims are typically moderate, not catastrophic

Insurance Premium Impact:

• Low base rates: Class 4 rates are significantly lower than Classes 1-3
• Example base rates: $1.10-$1.60 per $100 of property value
• Premium for $1M building: $11,000-$16,000 annually
• Relative cost: 1.1-1.5x higher than Class 6

Growing Standard: Class 4 is increasingly common for new commercial construction.

Class 5: Steel Frame with Protected Steel

Definition: Buildings with reinforced concrete or steel frame with complete fire protection of all structural elements.

Characteristics:

• Exterior walls: Masonry or non-combustible cladding
• Structural frame: Steel completely protected with non-combustible fire-resistant materials
• Roof: Non-combustible
• Interior structure: All steel components are fire-protected
• Fire rating: All structural elements meet fire-rating requirements
• Examples: Modern high-rise buildings, premium office buildings, contemporary mixed-use developments

Fire Behavior:

• Excellent fire resistance: Complete protection of all structural elements
• Maximum compartmentalization: Fire contained to smallest possible area
• Structural integrity assured: Building structure maintains full integrity through fire
• Minimal loss severity: Fire damage typically limited to contents and immediate area
• Minimal loss history: Insurance claims are typically very modest

Insurance Premium Impact:

• Very low base rates: Class 5 rates are among the lowest
• Example base rates: $0.75-$1.10 per $100 of property value
• Premium for $1M building: $7,500-$11,000 annually
• Relative cost: 1.05-1.3x higher than Class 6

Premium Advantage: A Class 5 building typically costs 20-30% less to insure than Class 4 building of similar size and occupancy.

Class 6: Steel and Concrete Non-Combustible (Fire-Resistive)

Definition: Buildings with reinforced concrete construction and/or steel frame with complete fire protection, providing maximum fire resistance.

Characteristics:

• Structural frame: Reinforced concrete with rebar throughout
• Exterior walls: Concrete, brick, or non-combustible with reinforced concrete backing
• Floors: Reinforced concrete decking
• Roof: Reinforced concrete or protected steel
• All structural elements: Fire-rated and protected
• Interior: Non-combustible elements
• Fire rating: All elements meet highest fire-rating standards
• Examples: Modern high-rise buildings, concrete parking structures, contemporary office towers, premium institutional buildings

Fire Behavior:

• Maximum fire resistance: Reinforced concrete is inherently fire-resistant
• Fire containment: Fire cannot spread through concrete structure
• Total structural integrity: Building remains fully structurally sound after even severe fire
• Minimal property damage: Fire damage is confined to immediate area and contents
• Minimal claims: Insurance claims from fire are minimal because structural loss is virtually impossible

Insurance Premium Impact:

• Lowest base rates: Class 6 has the lowest insurance rates of any construction class
• Example base rates: $0.65-$1.00 per $100 of property value
• Premium for $1M building: $6,500-$10,000 annually
• Baseline for comparison: All other classes are compared to Class 6

Premium Advantage: Class 6 buildings typically cost 50-70% LESS to insure than Class 1 buildings of similar size and occupancy.

Comparative Premium Analysis

To illustrate the dramatic impact of construction class, consider identical buildings of $1 million value in the same location with the same business occupancy:

| Construction Class | Example Building | Base Rate | Annual Premium | |---|---|---|---| | Class 1 | Wood warehouse | $4.00/100 | $40,000 | | Class 2 | Brick with wood roof | $2.25/100 | $22,500 | | Class 3 | Masonry building | $1.75/100 | $17,500 | | Class 4 | Steel frame building | $1.25/100 | $12,500 | | Class 5 | Modern office tower | $0.90/100 | $9,000 | | Class 6 | Concrete high-rise | $0.75/100 | $7,500 |

Premium Difference: The Class 1 building costs $32,500 MORE annually than the Class 6 building—simply due to construction differences. Over 10 years, that's $325,000 in additional insurance costs.

Evaluating Your Building's Construction Class

Self-Assessment Steps

To understand your building's likely construction class:

Step 1: Examine Exterior Walls

• Are they primarily wood? → Likely Class 1-2
• Are they primarily masonry (brick, concrete block)? → Likely Class 2-3
• Are they modern non-combustible? → Likely Class 4-6

Step 2: Examine Roof Structure

• Can you see wood rafters/decking in attic? → Class 1-2
• Is roof a concrete or steel structure? → Class 4-6
• Is roof metal/tile over non-combustible structure? → Class 3-4

Step 3: Examine Structural Frame

• Are major structural elements wood? → Class 1
• Are they steel with concrete protection? → Class 4-5
• Are they reinforced concrete? → Class 5-6

Step 4: Building Age

• Pre-1900: Almost certainly Class 1-2
• 1900-1950: Likely Class 2-3
• 1950-1980: Likely Class 3-4
• 1980-2000: Likely Class 4-5
• Post-2000: Likely Class 5-6

Request Official Classification

Your insurance broker should have your building's official construction class on file. Request this documentation to:

• Verify your current classification
• Understand the basis for your premium
• Identify if reclassification is possible through improvements

Professional Assessment

For significant investments, a professional building assessment by a structural engineer or insurance consultant can:

• Provide authoritative classification
• Identify possible improvement opportunities
• Estimate cost of upgrades
• Project insurance savings from improvements

Construction and Other COPE Factors

Construction doesn't exist in isolation—it interacts with other COPE factors:

Construction + Protection

Strong Construction (Class 5-6) + Excellent Protection:

• Base rate: $0.85/100
• Sprinkler credit: -25%
• Final rate: $0.64/100

Weak Construction (Class 1-2) + Excellent Protection:

• Base rate: $3.50/100
• Sprinkler credit: -35% (more valuable in combustible building)
• Final rate: $2.28/100

Lesson: Fire protection is more valuable in combustible buildings but can only partially offset construction disadvantage.

Construction + Occupancy

Strong Construction (Class 5-6) + Low Hazard Occupancy:

• Rate: ~$0.65/100

Strong Construction (Class 5-6) + High Hazard Occupancy:

• Rate: ~$1.50/100 or more

Lesson: Construction provides baseline protection, but high-hazard occupancy can override construction advantage.

Construction + Exposure

A Class 6 steel and concrete building in a high-exposure area (near chemical plant, in earthquake zone) might have higher premium than Class 4 building in low-exposure area.

Renovation and Construction Improvement

If you own or manage a Class 1, 2, or 3 building, you may wonder if renovation to improve construction classification is justified.

Roof Replacement: Class 2 → Class 3

Investment: Replacing wood roof with non-combustible material

• Typical cost: $15-30/sq ft × building square footage
• For 10,000 sq ft building: $150,000-$300,000

Insurance Savings:

• Annual premium reduction: 10-20%
• For a $15,000 annual premium building: $1,500-$3,000/year savings
• Payback period: 50-200 years (not financially justified for insurance alone)

Other Benefits:

• Improved fire safety
• Longer roof life
• Reduced maintenance
• Potential property value increase
• Customer/stakeholder perception

Verdict: Roof replacement is justified for other reasons (maintenance, safety, value) but insurance savings alone don't justify the investment.

Exterior Wall Upgrade: Class 1 → Class 3

Investment: Replacing combustible exterior with masonry

• Very expensive ($50-150/sq ft)
• For 5,000 sq ft exterior: $250,000-$750,000
• Typically only justified during building rehabilitation

Insurance Savings:

• Annual premium reduction: 30-50%
• Would need to save $7,500-$20,000+ annually to justify over 30 years
• Only realistic for buildings with very high current premiums

Verdict: Rarely justified for insurance reasons alone; considered when major renovation is planned for other reasons.

Strategic Thinking

Rather than expensive construction upgrades, focus on:

1. Maintaining current building condition - Prevent deterioration that could worsen class
2. Fire protection systems - More cost-effective way to reduce premium
3. Occupancy management - Control what happens inside the building
4. When renovating, incorporate better construction materials where economically feasible

Construction Class Disputes and Appeals

Occasionally, property owners believe their construction class is incorrectly assigned. If you believe this is the case:

Requesting Reclassification

1. Document your building's characteristics - Photos, structural drawings, architect specifications
2. Request formal inspection - Ask your insurer or ISO to conduct official classification review
3. Provide evidence - Historical records, renovation documentation, structural evidence
4. Consider professional assessment - Structural engineer's report may support reclassification claim

Common Reclassification Scenarios

• Wood building with fire-rated interior protection - May support higher class
• Building with unexpected construction - Sometimes buildings are built to higher standard than appearance suggests
• Major renovation with improved materials - Documented improvements may support reclassification
• Historical records showing upgraded construction - Past records may reveal standard not apparent today

Reality: Reclassification is possible but requires strong evidence and professional documentation. Insurance companies have extensive experience with building classifications.

Key Takeaway

Construction—the "C" in COPE—is the most dramatic factor affecting your commercial property insurance premium. The six construction classes create a systematic framework for assessing fire resistance, ranging from highly combustible wood-frame construction (Class 1) to extremely fire-resistant reinforced concrete construction (Class 6).

Understanding your building's construction class helps you:

• Understand your property insurance costs
• Evaluate property acquisition decisions with full cost picture
• Plan strategic improvements
• Make informed decisions about building value and risk

For most property owners, rather than expensive construction upgrades, the more practical approach is to optimize the other COPE factors—particularly Protection (fire suppression systems) which provides more cost-effective premium reduction.

---

Ready to understand your building's construction classification impact? The Volare Risk Management team can provide a detailed construction assessment and identify cost-effective ways to optimize your property insurance premium.