Exposure (E): External Hazards and Location Risk

The "E" in COPE stands for Exposure, and it represents external hazards that exist primarily due to your building's location rather than the building itself or what happens inside. While Construction, Occupancy, and Protection are primarily within the building, Exposure looks beyond—to the surrounding environment and location risks.

Exposure is unique among COPE factors because it's almost entirely outside your control. You cannot change where your building is located. However, understanding exposure factors helps you evaluate location decisions when buying or leasing properties, and it explains why identical buildings in different locations have different insurance costs.

The Exposure Principle

The fundamental principle of Exposure is: external hazards surrounding a building can create loss potential that's independent of the building's construction or operations.

Insurance companies recognize that:

• Natural disasters (earthquakes, hurricanes, flooding) are location-specific
• Man-made hazards (chemical plants, highways, railroads) create external threats
• Fire spread from nearby buildings can threaten your property
• Infrastructure quality (distance to fire hydrants, fire department response) varies by location
• Crime and theft rates vary significantly by geography

These external factors, beyond your control, affect your property insurance cost.

Natural Hazards

Natural hazards are weather and geological risks associated with your location.

Wind and Tornado Exposure

Definition: Geographic areas with elevated wind or tornado risk.

Affected Regions:

• Tornado Alley: Central United States (Texas, Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska)
• Coastal areas: Hurricane risk in Atlantic and Gulf coasts
• Mountain passes: Elevated wind exposure in some areas
• Exposed terrain: Open areas with high wind velocity

Risk Assessment Factors:

• Tornado history: Has the location experienced tornadoes?
• Building elevation: Exposed hilltops vs. sheltered locations
• Nearby structures: Wind protection from neighboring buildings
• Building orientation: Building shape and exposure to prevailing winds
• Vegetation: Trees or natural wind breaks nearby

Premium Impact:

• Low wind exposure: Base rate
• Moderate wind exposure: +5% to +15% surcharge
• High tornado exposure: +15% to +40% surcharge
• Extreme exposure (coastal hurricane area): +25% to +75%+ surcharge

Mitigation Possibilities:

• Limited: Wind exposure is geographic and difficult to mitigate
• Structural improvements (wind bracing, reinforced roof): Modest impact
• Relocation is only effective mitigation

Hail Exposure

Definition: Geographic risk of hail damage to building and contents.

Affected Regions:

• Hail Belt: Eastern Colorado, Nebraska, Wyoming (frequent hail)
• Great Plains: Elevated hail risk across central United States
• Mountain areas: Higher elevations with hail potential
• Specific locations: Some areas experience hail frequently, others rarely

Risk Assessment:

• Hail history: Frequency of damaging hail events
• Building material: Metal roofs more resistant; composition shingles more vulnerable
• Roof age: Older roofs more vulnerable to hail damage
• Elevation: Higher elevations more exposed to hail

Premium Impact:

• Low hail exposure: Base rate
• Moderate hail exposure: +5% to +15% surcharge
• High hail exposure: +15% to +50% surcharge
• Extreme exposure: +50%+ surcharge

Mitigation Through Maintenance:

• Regular roof inspection and maintenance
• Prompt replacement of damaged shingles
• Impact-resistant roofing materials may reduce surcharge 5-10%

Flood Exposure

Definition: Geographic risk of flood damage from heavy rain, river overflow, or storm surge.

Affected Areas:

• 100-year floodplain: Geographic areas with 1% annual flood probability
• 500-year floodplain: Areas with 0.2% annual flood probability
• Coastal zones: Storm surge risk during hurricanes
• River valleys: Properties near rivers with historical flooding
• Poor drainage areas: Low-lying areas prone to water accumulation

Risk Levels:

• Very high risk (frequent flooding): Properties in flood-prone areas
• High risk (100-year floodplain): Significant flood probability
• Moderate risk (elevated but outside floodplain): Some flood risk
• Low risk (outside floodplain, good drainage): Minimal flood risk

Insurance Coverage Issue:

• Standard property insurance typically excludes flood damage
• Flood insurance requires separate policy (through National Flood Insurance Program or private insurers)
• Building in flood-prone area requires flood insurance to be fully protected

Premium Impact:

• Outside floodplain: Base rate for property insurance
• 1% annual flood risk: May require flood insurance; property insurance surcharge +10% to +50%
• High flood risk: Flood insurance required; may be difficult to obtain property insurance

Mitigation Strategies:

• Elevation: Raising building above base flood elevation (expensive but effective)
• Flood vents: Allowing water through foundation to equalize pressure
• Sump pumps: Removing water accumulation
• Improved drainage: Grading and drainage improvements
• These may reduce premium 5-10% but don't eliminate flood exposure

Earthquake Exposure

Definition: Geographic risk of earthquake damage.

High-Risk Areas:

• California: Significant earthquake risk, especially near fault lines
• Pacific Northwest: Washington, Oregon, Northern California
• Mid-America: Seismic zones in Tennessee, Arkansas, Missouri
• Other areas: Limited but present seismic risk

Building Vulnerability:

• Vulnerable construction: Unreinforced masonry, old wood buildings
• Resilient construction: Reinforced concrete, modern steel buildings
• Base isolation: Special systems to reduce earthquake damage
• Seismic bracing: Special reinforcement for equipment and contents

Insurance Coverage Issue:

• Earthquake damage is typically excluded from standard property insurance
• Earthquake insurance requires separate endorsement
• Coverage is expensive in high-risk areas

Premium Impact:

• Outside earthquake zone: Base rate
• Low to moderate risk: Earthquake coverage available at additional cost
• High-risk area (California): Earthquake insurance is expensive or limited

Mitigation Through Building Design:

• Building seismic reinforcement: Expensive but can reduce earthquake insurance cost 10-30%
• Base isolation systems: Very expensive, substantial cost reduction
• Most viable mitigation is modern construction in high-risk areas

Winter Storm and Ice Exposure

Definition: Risk of winter storms, ice dams, and ice damage.

Affected Regions:

• Northern climates with regular winter weather
• Areas with temperature cycling (freeze-thaw cycles)
• Coastal areas with ice storm potential

Risk Factors:

• Building design: Roof shape affects ice dam formation
• Drainage: Proper gutter systems reduce water damage
• Insulation: Improved attic insulation reduces risk
• Heating system: Ensuring building stays above freezing

Premium Impact: Modest (+0% to +10% depending on severity and building design)

Mitigation:

• Proper attic insulation: Reduces ice dam formation
• Gutter maintenance: Prevents water backup
• Heat tape: Prevents ice dam formation
• Regular maintenance: Prompt snow removal and gutter cleaning

Man-Made Hazards

Beyond natural disasters, human infrastructure creates external hazards.

Proximity to Hazardous Industries

Chemical Plants and Refineries:

• Risk: Chemical release, explosion, fire spreading to nearby buildings
• Hazard distance: Even substantial distance creates some risk
• Premium impact: +10% to +50%+ depending on proximity and hazard type
• Example: Building 0.25 miles from refinery faces significant surcharge

Propane and Natural Gas Facilities:

• Risk: Explosion or fire affecting nearby buildings
• Premium impact: +5% to +25% depending on distance

Explosive Manufacturing:

• Risk: Explosion damage to nearby buildings
• Premium impact: +15% to +50%+ (very significant)
• Availability issue: May be uninsurable near extreme hazards

Hazardous Waste Sites:

• Risk: Contamination affecting property value and insurability
• Premium impact: May impact insurability rather than just premium

Mitigation: Very limited; relocation is only effective solution.

Proximity to Railroads

Risk: Train derailment affecting nearby properties

• Distance factor: Risk decreases with distance from tracks
• Cargo: Hazardous material trains create higher risk than freight trains
• Frequency: High-traffic rail lines pose greater risk

Premium Impact:

• Adjacent to active rail: +5% to +25% surcharge
• Moderate distance (0.25-0.5 miles): +0% to +10%
• Distance > 0.5 miles: Minimal to no surcharge

Mitigation: Difficult; relocation or living with surcharge.

Proximity to Highways

Risk: Vehicle accidents affecting nearby buildings

• Road type: Interstate highways create different risk than local roads
• Distance factor: Risk decreases with distance
• Traffic volume: High-traffic corridors create higher risk
• Hazardous materials: Truck traffic carrying hazmat elevates risk

Premium Impact:

• Immediately adjacent: +2% to +8% surcharge
• Moderate distance (100+ feet): Minimal impact
• Separated by significant distance: No surcharge

Mitigation: Some structural improvements (reinforced walls, windows) may reduce slightly.

Airport Proximity

Risk: Aircraft accidents affecting nearby buildings

• Distance: Risk is very close to airport (typically within few miles)
• Building type: Cargo facilities create higher risk than offices
• Frequency: Airport activity affects exposure

Premium Impact:

• Very close to airport: +5% to +20%
• Moderate distance: Minimal to no impact
• Distance > 3-5 miles: No airport surcharge

Power Line Proximity

Risk: Electrical hazard from overhead power lines

• Voltage level: High-voltage transmission lines create higher hazard
• Proximity: Distance affects degree of hazard
• Vegetation: Trees near lines create additional hazard

Premium Impact: Minimal (+0% to +3%)

Presence of Nearby Vacant or Deteriorated Buildings

Risk: Fire spreading from adjacent abandoned buildings

• Neighborhood quality: Deteriorated neighborhoods have higher fire spread risk
• Building density: Dense urban areas with older buildings pose higher risk
• Fire department response: Declining neighborhoods may have slower response

Premium Impact: +0% to +10% depending on severity

Fire Department Response and Water Supply

Infrastructure quality affects exposure rating:

Fire Department Response Time

Definition: How quickly fire department reaches building after call.

Factors Affecting Response Time:

• Distance to fire station: Closer stations = faster response
• Department type: Professional departments vs. volunteer departments
• Call volume: Busy departments may be slower
• Staffing: Adequate staffing ensures rapid response

Insurance Impact:

• Professional department < 5 miles away: Standard rate
• Professional department 5-10 miles away: Slight surcharge +0% to +5%
• Professional department > 10 miles away: +5% to +15% surcharge
• Volunteer-only department: +10% to +25% surcharge
• Very remote (30+ minutes response): +25% to +50%+ surcharge or potentially uninsurable

Water Supply for Fire Fighting

Definition: Availability of water for fire department use.

Water Sources:

• Fire hydrants: Direct connection to municipal water system (best)
• Tanker trucks: Fire department carries water (limited supply)
• Ponds or natural water: Less reliable source
• Private water systems: May be inadequate

Proximity to Hydrants:

• Close (within 500 feet): Excellent water supply; standard rate
• Moderate (500-1,000 feet): Good water supply; minimal surcharge
• Distant (1,000+ feet): Limited water supply; +5% to +15% surcharge
• No hydrant access: May incur +25% to +50% surcharge

Insurance Grade Classification

Insurance companies rate individual addresses based on:

• Fire department response capability
• Water supply adequacy
• Overall fire protection infrastructure

ISO Grade System:

• Class 1: Excellent fire protection (professional department, good water supply)
• Class 5: Adequate fire protection
• Class 10: Limited fire protection (remote or volunteer)

Premium Impact: Grades can create 20-30% variance in premium based solely on infrastructure.

Crime and Theft Exposure

Geographic crime rates affect property insurance:

High-Crime Areas

Risk Factors:

• Neighborhood crime rate: Statistical crime data for area
• Surrounding business: Adjacent uses (bars, adult entertainment, poor-quality retail)
• Vacant properties: Indicators of neighborhood decline
• Lighting: Adequate street lighting affects crime
• Police presence: Visibility of police patrols

Premium Impact: +0% to +15% depending on area crime rate

Mitigation:

• Security measures: Alarms, cameras, improved locks
• Good lighting: Exterior lighting deters crime
• Neighborhood involvement: Being part of community crime watch
• Relocation: Only complete mitigation

Burglary and Theft Risk

Building-specific factors:

• Location visibility: Hidden buildings harder to target
• Accessibility: Ease of access to building
• Neighboring uses: Commercial vs. residential affects break-in risk

Mitigation:

• Security system: Alarm system with monitoring
• Surveillance: Cameras and visible security measures
• Access control: Limited entry points, key card systems

Evaluating Exposure for Property Decisions

If you're considering purchasing or leasing a property, exposure factors should inform your decision:

Location Assessment Checklist

Natural Hazards:

• What is the flood risk? (in floodplain? 100-year floodplain?)
• What is the earthquake risk? (fault line proximity?)
• What is the wind/tornado risk? (geographic location?)
• What is the hail exposure? (regional hail frequency?)

Man-Made Hazards:

• Proximity to chemical plants or refineries? (how far?)
• Proximity to railroads? (what types of cargo?)
• Proximity to highways? (traffic volume, hazmat exposure?)
• Proximity to airport? (distance and activity level?)
• Proximity to industrial facilities? (types and hazards?)

Infrastructure:

• Distance to nearest fire station? (response time?)
• Type of fire department? (professional or volunteer?)
• Fire hydrant proximity? (adequate water supply?)
• Police response capability? (crime/theft protection?)

Neighborhood Quality:

• Crime rate for area? (compared to region?)
• Building maintenance? (area quality indicators?)
• Vacancy rates? (declining or stable neighborhood?)

Impact on Total Insurance Cost

Remember that Exposure is just one of four COPE factors:

• Strong Construction + Good Protection + Favorable Occupancy + Poor Exposure: Moderate premium
• Weak Construction + Limited Protection + Hazardous Occupancy + Excellent Exposure: High premium
• Excellent in all factors including low Exposure: Lowest premiums

Strategic Perspective: A location with poor exposure (high hazard) might still be worthwhile if other building characteristics are strong (modern construction, excellent protection systems, low-hazard occupancy).

Exposure and Insurance Underwriting

Understanding Exposure helps in insurance discussions:

Disclosure Requirements

You must disclose:

• Proximity to hazardous facilities
• History of losses due to external events
• Known environmental issues
• Flooding history
• Any unusual external hazards

Non-disclosure: Failure to disclose known exposures can result in claim denial.

Coverage Limitations

Some extreme exposures have coverage limitations:

• Flood: Often excluded; requires separate flood insurance
• Earthquake: Often excluded; requires separate earthquake coverage
• War/terrorism: Sometimes excluded for properties in extreme hazard areas

Premium Negotiation

Understanding exposure factors helps in negotiations:

• If exposure is worse than underwriter realizes, get assessment
• If exposure is better than assumed, provide documentation
• Some exposures can be partially offset by strong protection systems

Key Takeaway

Exposure—the "E" in COPE—represents external hazards and location risks that are largely outside your control. These include natural hazards (floods, earthquakes, wind, hail), man-made hazards (nearby industrial facilities, railroads, highways), and infrastructure factors (fire department response, water supply, crime rates).

Unlike Construction (largely fixed but renovatable), Occupancy (controllable through business decisions), and Protection (controllable through system installation), Exposure is almost entirely determined by location. For property owners, understanding exposure factors is critical for:

• Evaluating property purchases with full cost picture
• Understanding why identical buildings in different locations have different premiums
• Planning appropriate insurance coverage
• Making informed decisions about property value and risk

While exposure cannot be changed (except through relocation), understanding these factors helps you make better decisions about property investment and ensures you obtain appropriate insurance coverage for the external hazards affecting your location.

---

Conclusion: The Complete COPE Framework

Now that you understand all four COPE factors:

• Construction (C): How the building is built
• Occupancy (O): What happens inside the building
• Protection (P): What safety systems are installed
• Exposure (E): What external hazards surround the building

You have a complete framework for understanding your commercial property insurance premium. Your premium reflects the combination of all four factors, with each contributing to the overall risk assessment.

Key insights across all factors:

• Some factors are largely fixed (Construction, Exposure)
• Some factors are controllable (Occupancy, Protection)
• Factors interact (protection is more valuable in combustible buildings)
• Understanding COPE helps identify cost optimization opportunities
• COPE framework helps evaluate property investments

---

Ready to understand your complete COPE profile? The Volare Risk Management team can conduct a comprehensive COPE assessment of your property and recommend specific improvements across all four factors that will reduce insurance costs while enhancing actual building safety and value.